Divergent predictions of carbon storage between two global land models:
attribution of the causes through traceability analysis

Rafique, Rashid; Xia, Jianyang; Hararuk, Oleksandra; Asrar, Ghassem R.; Leng, Guoyong; Wang, Yingping; Luo, Yiqi

doi:10.5194/esd-7-649-2016

Articles | Volume 7, issue 3

https://doi.org/10.5194/esd-7-649-2016

© Author(s) 2016. This work is distributed under
the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.

https://doi.org/10.5194/esd-7-649-2016

© Author(s) 2016. This work is distributed under
the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.

Articles | Volume 7, issue 3

Research article

|

29 Jul 2016

Research article |

| 29 Jul 2016

Divergent predictions of carbon storage between two global land models: attribution of the causes through traceability analysis

Rashid Rafique, Jianyang Xia, Oleksandra Hararuk, Ghassem R. Asrar, Guoyong Leng, Yingping Wang, and Yiqi Luo

Viewed

Total article views: 3,826 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)

HTML	PDF	XML	Total	Supplement	BibTeX	EndNote
2,246	1,357	223	3,826	294	209	270

HTML: 2,246
PDF: 1,357
XML: 223
Total: 3,826
Supplement: 294
BibTeX: 209
EndNote: 270

Views and downloads (calculated since 27 Aug 2015)

Month	HTML	PDF	XML	Total
Aug 2015	86	39	1	126
Sep 2015	35	86	3	124
Oct 2015	31	41	1	73
Nov 2015	18	55	2	75
Dec 2015	6	39	0	45
Jan 2016	10	7	2	19
Feb 2016	20	8	1	29
Mar 2016	13	13	1	27
Apr 2016	28	4	1	33
May 2016	16	4	0	20
Jun 2016	12	5	1	18
Jul 2016	23	5	4	32
Aug 2016	90	27	0	117
Sep 2016	66	25	1	92
Oct 2016	51	10	0	61
Nov 2016	16	8	1	25
Dec 2016	7	4	1	12
Jan 2017	19	5	0	24
Feb 2017	16	4	4	24
Mar 2017	27	11	3	41
Apr 2017	39	13	4	56
May 2017	34	15	1	50
Jun 2017	38	16	2	56
Jul 2017	23	8	0	31
Aug 2017	12	6	0	18
Sep 2017	8	5	0	13
Oct 2017	6	7	0	13
Nov 2017	12	12	1	25
Dec 2017	13	7	0	20
Jan 2018	7	5	0	12
Feb 2018	13	4	2	19
Mar 2018	12	7	1	20
Apr 2018	9	6	0	15
May 2018	8	8	0	16
Jun 2018	7	8	0	15
Jul 2018	11	12	3	26
Aug 2018	14	6	0	20
Sep 2018	10	6	1	17
Oct 2018	11	8	2	21
Nov 2018	10	8	1	19
Dec 2018	4	4	1	9
Jan 2019	4	3	1	8
Feb 2019	5	4	0	9
Mar 2019	3	4	0	7
Apr 2019	1	3	1	5
May 2019	8	6	1	15
Jun 2019	5	9	1	15
Jul 2019	3	5	0	8
Aug 2019	9	7	0	16
Sep 2019	5	6	0	11
Oct 2019	10	8	0	18
Nov 2019	11	8	0	19
Dec 2019	9	3	3	15
Jan 2020	9	3	0	12
Feb 2020	11	3	0	14
Mar 2020	5	7	0	12
Apr 2020	9	7	2	18
May 2020	1	0	1
Jun 2020	32	17	3	52
Jul 2020	40	32	31	103
Aug 2020	8	10	3	21
Sep 2020	8	6	0	14
Oct 2020	13	10	1	24
Nov 2020	13	7	0	20
Dec 2020	14	14	1	29
Jan 2021	17	12	1	30
Feb 2021	7	8	0	15
Mar 2021	10	9	1	20
Apr 2021	8	7	3	18
May 2021	14	10	3	27
Jun 2021	6	11	1	18
Jul 2021	7	9	3	19
Aug 2021	7	13	1	21
Sep 2021	13	10	5	28
Oct 2021	14	48	2	64
Nov 2021	17	21	4	42
Dec 2021	18	14	5	37
Jan 2022	11	16	0	27
Feb 2022	8	7	2	17
Mar 2022	13	4	0	17
Apr 2022	15	9	1	25
May 2022	7	3	2	12
Jun 2022	10	3	1	14
Jul 2022	10	7	1	18
Aug 2022	12	3	3	18
Sep 2022	6	5	2	13
Oct 2022	12	7	1	20
Nov 2022	24	7	1	32
Dec 2022	12	7	3	22
Jan 2023	9	12	2	23
Feb 2023	15	7	2	24
Mar 2023	32	9	3	44
Apr 2023	10	4	1	15
May 2023	33	9	2	44
Jun 2023	32	4	0	36
Jul 2023	13	4	0	17
Aug 2023	15	6	3	24
Sep 2023	10	7	1	18
Oct 2023	17	5	2	24
Nov 2023	8	4	0	12
Dec 2023	14	4	1	19
Jan 2024	15	4	1	20
Feb 2024	12	6	2	20
Mar 2024	13	14	1	28
Apr 2024	22	4	9	35
May 2024	11	15	4	30
Jun 2024	23	9	1	33
Jul 2024	15	5	6	26
Aug 2024	38	3	5	46
Sep 2024	22	4	1	27
Oct 2024	20	6	1	27
Nov 2024	6	6	0	12
Dec 2024	5	6	2	13
Jan 2025	23	5	2	30
Feb 2025	19	6	1	26
Mar 2025	10	5	1	16
Apr 2025	14	16	1	31
May 2025	20	8	2	30
Jun 2025	54	17	1	72
Jul 2025	36	14	5	55
Aug 2025	30	7	2	39
Sep 2025	60	23	1	84
Oct 2025	19	25	3	47
Nov 2025	41	16	2	59
Dec 2025	17	22	2	41
Jan 2026	38	21	5	64
Feb 2026	33	8	4	45
Mar 2026	18	3	1	22

Cumulative views and downloads (calculated since 27 Aug 2015)

Month	HTML	PDF	XML	Total
Aug 2015	86	39	1	126
Sep 2015	35	86	3	124
Oct 2015	31	41	1	73
Nov 2015	18	55	2	75
Dec 2015	6	39	0	45
Jan 2016	10	7	2	19
Feb 2016	20	8	1	29
Mar 2016	13	13	1	27
Apr 2016	28	4	1	33
May 2016	16	4	0	20
Jun 2016	12	5	1	18
Jul 2016	23	5	4	32
Aug 2016	90	27	0	117
Sep 2016	66	25	1	92
Oct 2016	51	10	0	61
Nov 2016	16	8	1	25
Dec 2016	7	4	1	12
Jan 2017	19	5	0	24
Feb 2017	16	4	4	24
Mar 2017	27	11	3	41
Apr 2017	39	13	4	56
May 2017	34	15	1	50
Jun 2017	38	16	2	56
Jul 2017	23	8	0	31
Aug 2017	12	6	0	18
Sep 2017	8	5	0	13
Oct 2017	6	7	0	13
Nov 2017	12	12	1	25
Dec 2017	13	7	0	20
Jan 2018	7	5	0	12
Feb 2018	13	4	2	19
Mar 2018	12	7	1	20
Apr 2018	9	6	0	15
May 2018	8	8	0	16
Jun 2018	7	8	0	15
Jul 2018	11	12	3	26
Aug 2018	14	6	0	20
Sep 2018	10	6	1	17
Oct 2018	11	8	2	21
Nov 2018	10	8	1	19
Dec 2018	4	4	1	9
Jan 2019	4	3	1	8
Feb 2019	5	4	0	9
Mar 2019	3	4	0	7
Apr 2019	1	3	1	5
May 2019	8	6	1	15
Jun 2019	5	9	1	15
Jul 2019	3	5	0	8
Aug 2019	9	7	0	16
Sep 2019	5	6	0	11
Oct 2019	10	8	0	18
Nov 2019	11	8	0	19
Dec 2019	9	3	3	15
Jan 2020	9	3	0	12
Feb 2020	11	3	0	14
Mar 2020	5	7	0	12
Apr 2020	9	7	2	18
May 2020	1	0	1
Jun 2020	32	17	3	52
Jul 2020	40	32	31	103
Aug 2020	8	10	3	21
Sep 2020	8	6	0	14
Oct 2020	13	10	1	24
Nov 2020	13	7	0	20
Dec 2020	14	14	1	29
Jan 2021	17	12	1	30
Feb 2021	7	8	0	15
Mar 2021	10	9	1	20
Apr 2021	8	7	3	18
May 2021	14	10	3	27
Jun 2021	6	11	1	18
Jul 2021	7	9	3	19
Aug 2021	7	13	1	21
Sep 2021	13	10	5	28
Oct 2021	14	48	2	64
Nov 2021	17	21	4	42
Dec 2021	18	14	5	37
Jan 2022	11	16	0	27
Feb 2022	8	7	2	17
Mar 2022	13	4	0	17
Apr 2022	15	9	1	25
May 2022	7	3	2	12
Jun 2022	10	3	1	14
Jul 2022	10	7	1	18
Aug 2022	12	3	3	18
Sep 2022	6	5	2	13
Oct 2022	12	7	1	20
Nov 2022	24	7	1	32
Dec 2022	12	7	3	22
Jan 2023	9	12	2	23
Feb 2023	15	7	2	24
Mar 2023	32	9	3	44
Apr 2023	10	4	1	15
May 2023	33	9	2	44
Jun 2023	32	4	0	36
Jul 2023	13	4	0	17
Aug 2023	15	6	3	24
Sep 2023	10	7	1	18
Oct 2023	17	5	2	24
Nov 2023	8	4	0	12
Dec 2023	14	4	1	19
Jan 2024	15	4	1	20
Feb 2024	12	6	2	20
Mar 2024	13	14	1	28
Apr 2024	22	4	9	35
May 2024	11	15	4	30
Jun 2024	23	9	1	33
Jul 2024	15	5	6	26
Aug 2024	38	3	5	46
Sep 2024	22	4	1	27
Oct 2024	20	6	1	27
Nov 2024	6	6	0	12
Dec 2024	5	6	2	13
Jan 2025	23	5	2	30
Feb 2025	19	6	1	26
Mar 2025	10	5	1	16
Apr 2025	14	16	1	31
May 2025	20	8	2	30
Jun 2025	54	17	1	72
Jul 2025	36	14	5	55
Aug 2025	30	7	2	39
Sep 2025	60	23	1	84
Oct 2025	19	25	3	47
Nov 2025	41	16	2	59
Dec 2025	17	22	2	41
Jan 2026	38	21	5	64
Feb 2026	33	8	4	45
Mar 2026	18	3	1	22

Latest update: 09 Mar 2026

Download

Article (1358 KB)
Full-text XML

Short summary

Traceability analysis was used to diagnose the causes of differences in simulating ecosystem carbon storage capacity between two land models: CLMA-CASA and CABLE. Results showed that the simulated ecosystem carbon storage capacity is largely influenced by the photosynthesis parameterization, residence time and organic matter decomposition.