Comment on "Polynomial cointegration tests of anthropogenic impact on global warming" by Beenstock et al. (2012) &ndash; some hazards in econometric modelling of climate change

Pretis, F.; Hendry, D. F.

doi:https://doi.org/10.5194/esd-4-375-2013

Articles | Volume 4, issue 2

https://doi.org/10.5194/esd-4-375-2013

© Author(s) 2013. This work is distributed under
the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.

https://doi.org/10.5194/esd-4-375-2013

© Author(s) 2013. This work is distributed under
the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.

Articles | Volume 4, issue 2

Peer-reviewed comment

|

22 Oct 2013

Peer-reviewed comment |

| 22 Oct 2013

Comment on "Polynomial cointegration tests of anthropogenic impact on global warming" by Beenstock et al. (2012) – some hazards in econometric modelling of climate change

F. Pretis and D. F. Hendry

Viewed

Total article views: 9,693 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)

HTML	PDF	XML	Total	BibTeX	EndNote
5,443	3,960	290	9,693	297	232

HTML: 5,443
PDF: 3,960
XML: 290
Total: 9,693
BibTeX: 297
EndNote: 232

Views and downloads (calculated since 06 Feb 2013)

Month	HTML	PDF	XML	Total
Feb 2013	436	585	2	1,023
Mar 2013	149	142	3	294
Apr 2013	87	102	2	191
May 2013	100	117	2	219
Jun 2013	55	72	3	130
Jul 2013	57	31	1	89
Aug 2013	19	23	0	42
Sep 2013	81	66	0	147
Oct 2013	211	84	0	295
Nov 2013	113	129	2	244
Dec 2013	97	60	8	165
Jan 2014	79	71	9	159
Feb 2014	144	52	8	204
Mar 2014	205	72	11	288
Apr 2014	109	72	13	194
May 2014	116	56	4	176
Jun 2014	77	76	3	156
Jul 2014	82	54	1	137
Aug 2014	49	56	2	107
Sep 2014	27	49	1	77
Oct 2014	40	43	3	86
Nov 2014	24	63	2	89
Dec 2014	70	65	3	138
Jan 2015	17	42	2	61
Feb 2015	22	19	2	43
Mar 2015	30	33	0	63
Apr 2015	32	25	2	59
May 2015	16	22	0	38
Jun 2015	35	30	0	65
Jul 2015	42	22	0	64
Aug 2015	18	19	0	37
Sep 2015	26	19	0	45
Oct 2015	35	16	3	54
Nov 2015	29	21	0	50
Dec 2015	13	27	0	40
Jan 2016	40	26	2	68
Feb 2016	22	34	1	57
Mar 2016	23	26	1	50
Apr 2016	15	12	1	28
May 2016	26	21	0	47
Jun 2016	17	7	0	24
Jul 2016	16	11	3	30
Aug 2016	9	5	2	16
Sep 2016	15	5	0	20
Oct 2016	17	5	0	22
Nov 2016	11	15	1	27
Dec 2016	14	11	1	26
Jan 2017	33	9	0	42
Feb 2017	20	4	6	30
Mar 2017	44	25	8	77
Apr 2017	61	30	6	97
May 2017	41	18	2	61
Jun 2017	42	11	5	58
Jul 2017	22	5	0	27
Aug 2017	20	8	0	28
Sep 2017	14	11	0	25
Oct 2017	19	8	0	27
Nov 2017	22	11	0	33
Dec 2017	14	6	1	21
Jan 2018	22	7	1	30
Feb 2018	34	6	4	44
Mar 2018	20	12	1	33
Apr 2018	23	42	2	67
May 2018	20	30	1	51
Jun 2018	13	16	1	30
Jul 2018	25	13	0	38
Aug 2018	40	15	0	55
Sep 2018	38	26	2	66
Oct 2018	40	14	2	56
Nov 2018	22	20	1	43
Dec 2018	24	8	1	33
Jan 2019	23	7	0	30
Feb 2019	20	11	0	31
Mar 2019	15	7	0	22
Apr 2019	28	12	0	40
May 2019	14	8	0	22
Jun 2019	18	16	1	35
Jul 2019	31	32	0	63
Aug 2019	41	28	5	74
Sep 2019	25	22	0	47
Oct 2019	19	11	1	31
Nov 2019	40	25	3	68
Dec 2019	34	26	2	62
Jan 2020	51	39	2	92
Feb 2020	35	16	1	52
Mar 2020	10	15	1	26
Apr 2020	8	8	0	16
May 2020	8	11	0	19
Jun 2020	24	12	2	38
Jul 2020	38	28	24	90
Aug 2020	13	10	6	29
Sep 2020	21	7	0	28
Oct 2020	8	7	0	15
Nov 2020	27	11	0	38
Dec 2020	36	13	0	49
Jan 2021	26	15	0	41
Feb 2021	22	10	0	32
Mar 2021	12	15	2	29
Apr 2021	20	17	1	38
May 2021	31	8	3	42
Jun 2021	11	7	2	20
Jul 2021	16	13	1	30
Aug 2021	17	16	2	35
Sep 2021	23	20	3	46
Oct 2021	57	33	1	91
Nov 2021	20	27	1	48
Dec 2021	19	15	3	37
Jan 2022	35	15	3	53
Feb 2022	17	15	1	33
Mar 2022	14	11	0	25
Apr 2022	19	11	2	32
May 2022	11	6	2	19
Jun 2022	12	4	0	16
Jul 2022	17	6	2	25
Aug 2022	10	8	1	19
Sep 2022	10	8	1	19
Oct 2022	15	7	4	26
Nov 2022	30	10	2	42
Dec 2022	25	17	1	43
Jan 2023	13	14	3	30
Feb 2023	13	4	2	19
Mar 2023	23	6	2	31
Apr 2023	11	9	0	20
May 2023	10	12	0	22
Jun 2023	37	7	1	45
Jul 2023	16	10	0	26
Aug 2023	11	7	3	21
Sep 2023	14	10	0	24
Oct 2023	16	16	0	32
Nov 2023	13	3	0	16
Dec 2023	26	11	1	38
Jan 2024	15	11	1	27
Feb 2024	10	10	2	22
Mar 2024	20	4	3	27
Apr 2024	25	4	5	34
May 2024	23	9	1	33
Jun 2024	26	7	1	34
Jul 2024	45	13	5	63
Aug 2024	50	6	1	57
Sep 2024	46	14	1	61
Oct 2024	38	11	1	50
Nov 2024	29	7	2	38
Dec 2024	26	25	9	60
Jan 2025	23	3	3	29
Feb 2025	27	8	2	37
Mar 2025	17	16	3	36
Apr 2025	29	12	0	41
May 2025	32	14	2	48
Jun 2025	40	12	2	54
Jul 2025	3	1	0	4

Cumulative views and downloads (calculated since 06 Feb 2013)

Month	HTML	PDF	XML	Total
Feb 2013	436	585	2	1,023
Mar 2013	149	142	3	294
Apr 2013	87	102	2	191
May 2013	100	117	2	219
Jun 2013	55	72	3	130
Jul 2013	57	31	1	89
Aug 2013	19	23	0	42
Sep 2013	81	66	0	147
Oct 2013	211	84	0	295
Nov 2013	113	129	2	244
Dec 2013	97	60	8	165
Jan 2014	79	71	9	159
Feb 2014	144	52	8	204
Mar 2014	205	72	11	288
Apr 2014	109	72	13	194
May 2014	116	56	4	176
Jun 2014	77	76	3	156
Jul 2014	82	54	1	137
Aug 2014	49	56	2	107
Sep 2014	27	49	1	77
Oct 2014	40	43	3	86
Nov 2014	24	63	2	89
Dec 2014	70	65	3	138
Jan 2015	17	42	2	61
Feb 2015	22	19	2	43
Mar 2015	30	33	0	63
Apr 2015	32	25	2	59
May 2015	16	22	0	38
Jun 2015	35	30	0	65
Jul 2015	42	22	0	64
Aug 2015	18	19	0	37
Sep 2015	26	19	0	45
Oct 2015	35	16	3	54
Nov 2015	29	21	0	50
Dec 2015	13	27	0	40
Jan 2016	40	26	2	68
Feb 2016	22	34	1	57
Mar 2016	23	26	1	50
Apr 2016	15	12	1	28
May 2016	26	21	0	47
Jun 2016	17	7	0	24
Jul 2016	16	11	3	30
Aug 2016	9	5	2	16
Sep 2016	15	5	0	20
Oct 2016	17	5	0	22
Nov 2016	11	15	1	27
Dec 2016	14	11	1	26
Jan 2017	33	9	0	42
Feb 2017	20	4	6	30
Mar 2017	44	25	8	77
Apr 2017	61	30	6	97
May 2017	41	18	2	61
Jun 2017	42	11	5	58
Jul 2017	22	5	0	27
Aug 2017	20	8	0	28
Sep 2017	14	11	0	25
Oct 2017	19	8	0	27
Nov 2017	22	11	0	33
Dec 2017	14	6	1	21
Jan 2018	22	7	1	30
Feb 2018	34	6	4	44
Mar 2018	20	12	1	33
Apr 2018	23	42	2	67
May 2018	20	30	1	51
Jun 2018	13	16	1	30
Jul 2018	25	13	0	38
Aug 2018	40	15	0	55
Sep 2018	38	26	2	66
Oct 2018	40	14	2	56
Nov 2018	22	20	1	43
Dec 2018	24	8	1	33
Jan 2019	23	7	0	30
Feb 2019	20	11	0	31
Mar 2019	15	7	0	22
Apr 2019	28	12	0	40
May 2019	14	8	0	22
Jun 2019	18	16	1	35
Jul 2019	31	32	0	63
Aug 2019	41	28	5	74
Sep 2019	25	22	0	47
Oct 2019	19	11	1	31
Nov 2019	40	25	3	68
Dec 2019	34	26	2	62
Jan 2020	51	39	2	92
Feb 2020	35	16	1	52
Mar 2020	10	15	1	26
Apr 2020	8	8	0	16
May 2020	8	11	0	19
Jun 2020	24	12	2	38
Jul 2020	38	28	24	90
Aug 2020	13	10	6	29
Sep 2020	21	7	0	28
Oct 2020	8	7	0	15
Nov 2020	27	11	0	38
Dec 2020	36	13	0	49
Jan 2021	26	15	0	41
Feb 2021	22	10	0	32
Mar 2021	12	15	2	29
Apr 2021	20	17	1	38
May 2021	31	8	3	42
Jun 2021	11	7	2	20
Jul 2021	16	13	1	30
Aug 2021	17	16	2	35
Sep 2021	23	20	3	46
Oct 2021	57	33	1	91
Nov 2021	20	27	1	48
Dec 2021	19	15	3	37
Jan 2022	35	15	3	53
Feb 2022	17	15	1	33
Mar 2022	14	11	0	25
Apr 2022	19	11	2	32
May 2022	11	6	2	19
Jun 2022	12	4	0	16
Jul 2022	17	6	2	25
Aug 2022	10	8	1	19
Sep 2022	10	8	1	19
Oct 2022	15	7	4	26
Nov 2022	30	10	2	42
Dec 2022	25	17	1	43
Jan 2023	13	14	3	30
Feb 2023	13	4	2	19
Mar 2023	23	6	2	31
Apr 2023	11	9	0	20
May 2023	10	12	0	22
Jun 2023	37	7	1	45
Jul 2023	16	10	0	26
Aug 2023	11	7	3	21
Sep 2023	14	10	0	24
Oct 2023	16	16	0	32
Nov 2023	13	3	0	16
Dec 2023	26	11	1	38
Jan 2024	15	11	1	27
Feb 2024	10	10	2	22
Mar 2024	20	4	3	27
Apr 2024	25	4	5	34
May 2024	23	9	1	33
Jun 2024	26	7	1	34
Jul 2024	45	13	5	63
Aug 2024	50	6	1	57
Sep 2024	46	14	1	61
Oct 2024	38	11	1	50
Nov 2024	29	7	2	38
Dec 2024	26	25	9	60
Jan 2025	23	3	3	29
Feb 2025	27	8	2	37
Mar 2025	17	16	3	36
Apr 2025	29	12	0	41
May 2025	32	14	2	48
Jun 2025	40	12	2	54
Jul 2025	3	1	0	4