the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.
Differences in carbon cycle and temperature projections from emission- and concentration-driven earth system model simulations
P. Shao
X. Zeng
Abstract. The influence of prognostic and prescribed atmospheric CO2 concentrations ([CO2]) on the carbon uptake and temperature is investigated using all eight Earth System Models (ESMs) with relevant output variables from the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 5 (CMIP5). Under the RCP8.5 scenario, the projected [CO2] differences in 2100 vary from −19.7 to +207.3 ppm in emission-driven ESMs. Incorporation of the interactive concentrations also increases the range of global warming, computed as the 20 year average difference between 2081–2100 and 1850–1869/1861–1880, by 49% from 2.36 K (i.e. ranging from 3.11 to 5.47 K) in the concentration-driven simulations to 3.51 K in the emission-driven simulations. The observed seasonal amplitude of global [CO2] from 1980–2011 is about 1.2–5.3 times as large as those from the eight emission-driven ESMs, while the [CO2] seasonality is simply neglected in concentration-driven ESMs, suggesting the urgent need of ESM improvements in this area. The temperature-concentration feedback parameter α is more sensitive to [CO2] (e.g. during 1980–2005 versus 2075–2100) than how [CO2] is handled (i.e. prognostic versus prescribed). This sensitivity can be substantially reduced by using a more appropriate parameter α' computed from the linear regression of temperature change versus that of the logarithm of [CO2]. However, the inter-model relative variations of both α and α' remain large, suggesting the need of more detailed studies to understand and hopefully reduce these discrepancies.
P. Shao et al.


-
RC C433: 'Review', Chris Jones, 18 Sep 2014
-
AC C495: 'Reply to Dr. Jones', Pu Shao, 07 Oct 2014
-
RC C498: 'response re carbon units', Chris Jones, 07 Oct 2014
-
AC C500: 'Reply about the carbon units', Pu Shao, 08 Oct 2014
-
AC C500: 'Reply about the carbon units', Pu Shao, 08 Oct 2014
-
RC C498: 'response re carbon units', Chris Jones, 07 Oct 2014
-
AC C495: 'Reply to Dr. Jones', Pu Shao, 07 Oct 2014
-
RC C441: 'Review', Anonymous Referee #2, 23 Sep 2014
-
RC C443: 'No new science', Anonymous Referee #3, 23 Sep 2014
-
AC C497: 'Reply to Referee #3', Pu Shao, 07 Oct 2014
-
AC C497: 'Reply to Referee #3', Pu Shao, 07 Oct 2014
-
AC C496: 'Reply to Referee #2', Pu Shao, 07 Oct 2014


-
RC C433: 'Review', Chris Jones, 18 Sep 2014
-
AC C495: 'Reply to Dr. Jones', Pu Shao, 07 Oct 2014
-
RC C498: 'response re carbon units', Chris Jones, 07 Oct 2014
-
AC C500: 'Reply about the carbon units', Pu Shao, 08 Oct 2014
-
AC C500: 'Reply about the carbon units', Pu Shao, 08 Oct 2014
-
RC C498: 'response re carbon units', Chris Jones, 07 Oct 2014
-
AC C495: 'Reply to Dr. Jones', Pu Shao, 07 Oct 2014
-
RC C441: 'Review', Anonymous Referee #2, 23 Sep 2014
-
RC C443: 'No new science', Anonymous Referee #3, 23 Sep 2014
-
AC C497: 'Reply to Referee #3', Pu Shao, 07 Oct 2014
-
AC C497: 'Reply to Referee #3', Pu Shao, 07 Oct 2014
-
AC C496: 'Reply to Referee #2', Pu Shao, 07 Oct 2014
P. Shao et al.
P. Shao et al.
Viewed
HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
898 | 335 | 78 | 1,311 | 71 | 99 |
- HTML: 898
- PDF: 335
- XML: 78
- Total: 1,311
- BibTeX: 71
- EndNote: 99