P. Björnbom
Top-of-the-Atmosphere (TOA) net radiative flux anomalies from Clouds and Earth's Radiant Energy Systems (CERES) Energy Balanced and Filled (EBAF) and surface air temperature anomalies from HadCRUT3 were compared for the time interval September 2000–May 2011. In a phase plane plot with the radiative flux anomalies lagging the temperature anomalies with 7 months the phase plane curve approached straight lines during about an eight months long period at the beginning and a five year period at the end of the interval. Both of those periods, but more clearly the latter one, could be connected to the occurrence of distinct El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO) episodes. This result is explained by using a hypothesis stating that non-radiative forcing connected to the ENSO is dominating the temperature changes during those two periods and that there is a lag between the temperature change and the radiative flux feedback. According to the hypothesis the slopes of the straight lines equal the value of the climate feedback parameter. By linear regression based on the mentioned five year period the value of the climate feedback parameter was estimated to 5.5 ± 0.6 W m−2 K−1 (± two standard errors).
Received: 16 Dec 2012 – Discussion started: 09 Jan 2013
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.
P. Björnbom
Viewed
Total article views: 8,130 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
6,824
1,130
176
8,130
185
200
HTML: 6,824
PDF: 1,130
XML: 176
Total: 8,130
BibTeX: 185
EndNote: 200
Views and downloads (calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Feb 2013
336
109
2
447
Mar 2013
155
55
1
211
Apr 2013
117
33
2
152
May 2013
31
26
0
57
Jun 2013
39
37
2
78
Jul 2013
36
22
0
58
Aug 2013
20
11
0
31
Sep 2013
320
15
0
335
Oct 2013
871
28
1
900
Nov 2013
446
17
0
463
Dec 2013
58
14
3
75
Jan 2014
69
20
3
92
Feb 2014
55
18
5
78
Mar 2014
58
17
5
80
Apr 2014
52
16
2
70
May 2014
37
13
0
50
Jun 2014
45
21
1
67
Jul 2014
37
12
0
49
Aug 2014
40
14
0
54
Sep 2014
39
18
0
57
Oct 2014
114
19
0
133
Nov 2014
113
24
2
139
Dec 2014
174
21
0
195
Jan 2015
69
7
0
76
Feb 2015
21
10
0
31
Mar 2015
23
5
0
28
Apr 2015
30
11
2
43
May 2015
21
10
0
31
Jun 2015
38
8
1
47
Jul 2015
49
12
4
65
Aug 2015
30
4
1
35
Sep 2015
25
6
0
31
Oct 2015
37
8
4
49
Nov 2015
51
13
1
65
Dec 2015
26
14
2
42
Jan 2016
39
12
3
54
Feb 2016
16
8
1
25
Mar 2016
26
4
0
30
Apr 2016
16
2
0
18
May 2016
40
6
2
48
Jun 2016
17
3
0
20
Jul 2016
14
2
1
17
Aug 2016
15
5
0
20
Sep 2016
12
2
0
14
Oct 2016
12
3
1
16
Nov 2016
12
2
1
15
Dec 2016
5
4
0
9
Jan 2017
19
7
1
27
Feb 2017
27
3
5
35
Mar 2017
69
7
76
Apr 2017
46
5
4
55
May 2017
38
3
4
45
Jun 2017
58
8
2
68
Jul 2017
27
2
0
29
Aug 2017
23
3
0
26
Sep 2017
12
0
12
Oct 2017
14
3
0
17
Nov 2017
12
2
0
14
Dec 2017
21
2
0
23
Jan 2018
17
1
0
18
Feb 2018
35
2
5
42
Mar 2018
17
4
3
24
Apr 2018
16
3
1
20
May 2018
23
6
2
31
Jun 2018
13
6
1
20
Jul 2018
21
4
1
26
Aug 2018
29
4
1
34
Sep 2018
30
7
1
38
Oct 2018
18
2
0
20
Nov 2018
29
8
0
37
Dec 2018
20
6
1
27
Jan 2019
30
7
1
38
Feb 2019
16
4
0
20
Mar 2019
15
4
1
20
Apr 2019
11
1
2
14
May 2019
10
3
0
13
Jun 2019
20
6
2
28
Jul 2019
23
4
0
27
Aug 2019
27
3
0
30
Sep 2019
15
7
0
22
Oct 2019
25
2
0
27
Nov 2019
24
2
0
26
Dec 2019
39
2
1
42
Jan 2020
29
1
0
30
Feb 2020
33
5
0
38
Mar 2020
11
1
0
12
Apr 2020
13
2
0
15
May 2020
13
2
0
15
Jun 2020
8
1
0
9
Jul 2020
10
6
7
23
Aug 2020
21
3
4
28
Sep 2020
13
3
2
18
Oct 2020
20
5
1
26
Nov 2020
31
7
3
41
Dec 2020
13
6
1
20
Jan 2021
25
6
1
32
Feb 2021
29
5
0
34
Mar 2021
27
6
0
33
Apr 2021
19
5
0
24
May 2021
34
3
1
38
Jun 2021
25
3
0
28
Jul 2021
26
2
1
29
Aug 2021
19
3
0
22
Sep 2021
27
2
1
30
Oct 2021
45
8
1
54
Nov 2021
51
5
1
57
Dec 2021
39
6
0
45
Jan 2022
26
7
1
34
Feb 2022
18
4
1
23
Mar 2022
23
3
1
27
Apr 2022
27
2
3
32
May 2022
34
4
0
38
Jun 2022
29
3
0
32
Jul 2022
23
2
0
25
Aug 2022
28
1
0
29
Sep 2022
33
4
0
37
Oct 2022
59
2
0
61
Nov 2022
75
6
2
83
Dec 2022
103
7
1
111
Jan 2023
105
5
0
110
Feb 2023
164
4
0
168
Mar 2023
106
3
1
110
Apr 2023
17
1
18
May 2023
28
6
1
35
Jun 2023
30
2
2
34
Jul 2023
20
6
0
26
Aug 2023
15
2
0
17
Sep 2023
16
1
1
18
Oct 2023
21
6
4
31
Nov 2023
19
0
19
Dec 2023
24
1
0
25
Jan 2024
23
4
1
28
Feb 2024
20
7
2
29
Mar 2024
16
1
2
19
Apr 2024
22
1
4
27
May 2024
19
2
1
22
Jun 2024
43
3
3
49
Jul 2024
19
2
3
24
Aug 2024
27
4
0
31
Sep 2024
9
5
0
14
Oct 2024
13
4
1
18
Nov 2024
23
1
2
26
Dec 2024
16
10
1
27
Jan 2025
20
1
1
22
Feb 2025
15
2
1
18
Mar 2025
8
5
2
15
Apr 2025
18
5
0
23
May 2025
22
7
4
33
Jun 2025
25
5
1
31
Jul 2025
21
7
3
31
Aug 2025
26
2
28
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Feb 2013
336
109
2
Mar 2013
491
164
3
Apr 2013
608
197
5
May 2013
639
223
5
Jun 2013
678
260
7
Jul 2013
714
282
7
Aug 2013
734
293
7
Sep 2013
1,054
308
7
Oct 2013
1,925
336
8
Nov 2013
2,371
353
8
Dec 2013
2,429
367
11
Jan 2014
2,498
387
14
Feb 2014
2,553
405
19
Mar 2014
2,611
422
24
Apr 2014
2,663
438
26
May 2014
2,700
451
26
Jun 2014
2,745
472
27
Jul 2014
2,782
484
27
Aug 2014
2,822
498
27
Sep 2014
2,861
516
27
Oct 2014
2,975
535
27
Nov 2014
3,088
559
29
Dec 2014
3,262
580
29
Jan 2015
3,331
587
29
Feb 2015
3,352
597
29
Mar 2015
3,375
602
29
Apr 2015
3,405
613
31
May 2015
3,426
623
31
Jun 2015
3,464
631
32
Jul 2015
3,513
643
36
Aug 2015
3,543
647
37
Sep 2015
3,568
653
37
Oct 2015
3,605
661
41
Nov 2015
3,656
674
42
Dec 2015
3,682
688
44
Jan 2016
3,721
700
47
Feb 2016
3,737
708
48
Mar 2016
3,763
712
48
Apr 2016
3,779
714
48
May 2016
3,819
720
50
Jun 2016
3,836
723
50
Jul 2016
3,850
725
51
Aug 2016
3,865
730
51
Sep 2016
3,877
732
51
Oct 2016
3,889
735
52
Nov 2016
3,901
737
53
Dec 2016
3,906
741
53
Jan 2017
3,925
748
54
Feb 2017
3,952
751
59
Mar 2017
4,021
751
66
Apr 2017
4,067
756
70
May 2017
4,105
759
74
Jun 2017
4,163
767
76
Jul 2017
4,190
769
76
Aug 2017
4,213
772
76
Sep 2017
4,225
772
76
Oct 2017
4,239
775
76
Nov 2017
4,251
777
76
Dec 2017
4,272
779
76
Jan 2018
4,289
780
76
Feb 2018
4,324
782
81
Mar 2018
4,341
786
84
Apr 2018
4,357
789
85
May 2018
4,380
795
87
Jun 2018
4,393
801
88
Jul 2018
4,414
805
89
Aug 2018
4,443
809
90
Sep 2018
4,473
816
91
Oct 2018
4,491
818
91
Nov 2018
4,520
826
91
Dec 2018
4,540
832
92
Jan 2019
4,570
839
93
Feb 2019
4,586
843
93
Mar 2019
4,601
847
94
Apr 2019
4,612
848
96
May 2019
4,622
851
96
Jun 2019
4,642
857
98
Jul 2019
4,665
861
98
Aug 2019
4,692
864
98
Sep 2019
4,707
871
98
Oct 2019
4,732
873
98
Nov 2019
4,756
875
98
Dec 2019
4,795
877
99
Jan 2020
4,824
878
99
Feb 2020
4,857
883
99
Mar 2020
4,868
884
99
Apr 2020
4,881
886
99
May 2020
4,894
888
99
Jun 2020
4,902
889
99
Jul 2020
4,912
895
106
Aug 2020
4,933
898
110
Sep 2020
4,946
901
112
Oct 2020
4,966
906
113
Nov 2020
4,997
913
116
Dec 2020
5,010
919
117
Jan 2021
5,035
925
118
Feb 2021
5,064
930
118
Mar 2021
5,091
936
118
Apr 2021
5,110
941
118
May 2021
5,144
944
119
Jun 2021
5,169
947
119
Jul 2021
5,195
949
120
Aug 2021
5,214
952
120
Sep 2021
5,241
954
121
Oct 2021
5,286
962
122
Nov 2021
5,337
967
123
Dec 2021
5,376
973
123
Jan 2022
5,402
980
124
Feb 2022
5,420
984
125
Mar 2022
5,443
987
126
Apr 2022
5,470
989
129
May 2022
5,504
993
129
Jun 2022
5,533
996
129
Jul 2022
5,556
998
129
Aug 2022
5,584
999
129
Sep 2022
5,617
1,003
129
Oct 2022
5,676
1,005
129
Nov 2022
5,751
1,011
131
Dec 2022
5,854
1,018
132
Jan 2023
5,959
1,023
132
Feb 2023
6,123
1,027
132
Mar 2023
6,229
1,030
133
Apr 2023
6,246
1,030
134
May 2023
6,274
1,036
135
Jun 2023
6,304
1,038
137
Jul 2023
6,324
1,044
137
Aug 2023
6,339
1,046
137
Sep 2023
6,355
1,047
138
Oct 2023
6,376
1,053
142
Nov 2023
6,395
1,053
142
Dec 2023
6,419
1,054
142
Jan 2024
6,442
1,058
143
Feb 2024
6,462
1,065
145
Mar 2024
6,478
1,066
147
Apr 2024
6,500
1,067
151
May 2024
6,519
1,069
152
Jun 2024
6,562
1,072
155
Jul 2024
6,581
1,074
158
Aug 2024
6,608
1,078
158
Sep 2024
6,617
1,083
158
Oct 2024
6,630
1,087
159
Nov 2024
6,653
1,088
161
Dec 2024
6,669
1,098
162
Jan 2025
6,689
1,099
163
Feb 2025
6,704
1,101
164
Mar 2025
6,712
1,106
166
Apr 2025
6,730
1,111
166
May 2025
6,752
1,118
170
Jun 2025
6,777
1,123
171
Jul 2025
6,798
1,130
174
Aug 2025
6,824
1,130
176
Saved
Discussed
Latest update: 27 Aug 2025