S. E. Schwartz
Attention is called to several inconsistencies and errors in the definition and interpretation of quantities relating to climate sensitivity and feedbacks in the discussions paper "Climate sensitivity in the Anthropocene" by Previdi et al. (2011).
This preprint has been withdrawn.
Received: 21 Feb 2012 – Discussion started: 28 Feb 2012
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this preprint. The responsibility to include appropriate place names lies with the authors.
S. E. Schwartz
Viewed
Total article views: 1,811 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
1,147
542
122
1,811
148
121
HTML: 1,147
PDF: 542
XML: 122
Total: 1,811
BibTeX: 148
EndNote: 121
Views and downloads (calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Jan 2013
7
10
1
18
Feb 2013
6
8
1
15
Mar 2013
6
8
1
15
Apr 2013
4
9
1
14
May 2013
9
8
1
18
Jun 2013
4
8
0
12
Jul 2013
4
8
1
13
Aug 2013
4
5
2
11
Sep 2013
5
11
0
16
Oct 2013
3
7
0
10
Nov 2013
4
9
1
14
Dec 2013
5
6
3
14
Jan 2014
6
6
2
14
Feb 2014
7
7
4
18
Mar 2014
10
12
5
27
Apr 2014
2
11
2
15
May 2014
2
7
1
10
Jun 2014
6
1
7
Jul 2014
3
9
0
12
Aug 2014
2
10
0
12
Sep 2014
7
0
7
Oct 2014
2
5
2
9
Nov 2014
3
7
0
10
Dec 2014
1
6
0
7
Jan 2015
2
7
0
9
Feb 2015
4
2
1
7
Mar 2015
2
3
0
5
Apr 2015
6
1
1
8
May 2015
0
Jun 2015
6
3
0
9
Jul 2015
7
9
0
16
Aug 2015
4
3
1
8
Sep 2015
1
3
0
4
Oct 2015
6
2
0
8
Nov 2015
6
2
0
8
Dec 2015
6
0
6
Jan 2016
13
5
1
19
Feb 2016
10
8
1
19
Mar 2016
8
1
0
9
Apr 2016
6
2
0
8
May 2016
6
1
0
7
Jun 2016
4
1
0
5
Jul 2016
7
5
1
13
Aug 2016
5
1
0
6
Sep 2016
5
0
5
Oct 2016
5
2
1
8
Nov 2016
4
0
4
Dec 2016
2
4
0
6
Jan 2017
6
4
0
10
Feb 2017
9
4
0
13
Mar 2017
14
1
0
15
Apr 2017
21
1
2
24
May 2017
25
3
4
32
Jun 2017
19
1
2
22
Jul 2017
4
0
4
Aug 2017
9
0
9
Sep 2017
3
1
0
4
Oct 2017
5
0
5
Nov 2017
7
1
0
8
Dec 2017
7
1
0
8
Jan 2018
8
1
0
9
Feb 2018
16
2
5
23
Mar 2018
9
3
2
14
Apr 2018
6
2
1
9
May 2018
9
3
1
13
Jun 2018
6
2
1
9
Jul 2018
7
1
1
9
Aug 2018
7
2
0
9
Sep 2018
7
8
1
16
Oct 2018
8
6
1
15
Nov 2018
11
4
0
15
Dec 2018
11
5
1
17
Jan 2019
8
4
0
12
Feb 2019
5
0
5
Mar 2019
6
3
1
10
Apr 2019
5
5
1
11
May 2019
2
2
1
5
Jun 2019
5
7
2
14
Jul 2019
8
2
0
10
Aug 2019
7
6
1
14
Sep 2019
7
1
0
8
Oct 2019
4
1
0
5
Nov 2019
9
2
0
11
Dec 2019
7
1
0
8
Jan 2020
14
2
0
16
Feb 2020
13
4
0
17
Mar 2020
4
1
1
6
Apr 2020
6
2
0
8
May 2020
4
2
0
6
Jun 2020
3
0
3
Jul 2020
11
7
5
23
Aug 2020
6
2
3
11
Sep 2020
4
4
0
8
Oct 2020
8
3
1
12
Nov 2020
5
3
1
9
Dec 2020
6
6
1
13
Jan 2021
26
7
0
33
Feb 2021
8
4
0
12
Mar 2021
6
3
0
9
Apr 2021
8
3
0
11
May 2021
23
5
3
31
Jun 2021
17
6
0
23
Jul 2021
10
2
1
13
Aug 2021
9
4
2
15
Sep 2021
10
2
0
12
Oct 2021
15
6
1
22
Nov 2021
12
1
0
13
Dec 2021
16
8
0
24
Jan 2022
23
6
1
30
Feb 2022
14
3
2
19
Mar 2022
13
4
1
18
Apr 2022
9
3
0
12
May 2022
7
2
0
9
Jun 2022
12
1
0
13
Jul 2022
3
5
0
8
Aug 2022
7
2
0
9
Sep 2022
2
4
0
6
Oct 2022
9
4
13
Nov 2022
18
6
1
25
Dec 2022
14
6
0
20
Jan 2023
5
3
0
8
Feb 2023
14
5
0
19
Mar 2023
16
2
0
18
Apr 2023
4
1
5
May 2023
7
7
2
16
Jun 2023
18
4
5
27
Jul 2023
7
2
1
10
Aug 2023
4
3
0
7
Sep 2023
10
3
1
14
Oct 2023
13
6
3
22
Nov 2023
11
1
0
12
Dec 2023
15
0
15
Jan 2024
14
1
15
Feb 2024
15
3
2
20
Mar 2024
19
4
2
25
Apr 2024
12
3
5
20
May 2024
12
1
0
13
Jun 2024
14
2
16
Jul 2024
13
6
4
23
Aug 2024
13
3
0
16
Sep 2024
6
3
0
9
Oct 2024
2
2
0
4
Nov 2024
3
1
1
5
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Jan 2013
7
10
1
Feb 2013
13
18
2
Mar 2013
19
26
3
Apr 2013
23
35
4
May 2013
32
43
5
Jun 2013
36
51
5
Jul 2013
40
59
6
Aug 2013
44
64
8
Sep 2013
49
75
8
Oct 2013
52
82
8
Nov 2013
56
91
9
Dec 2013
61
97
12
Jan 2014
67
103
14
Feb 2014
74
110
18
Mar 2014
84
122
23
Apr 2014
86
133
25
May 2014
88
140
26
Jun 2014
88
146
27
Jul 2014
91
155
27
Aug 2014
93
165
27
Sep 2014
93
172
27
Oct 2014
95
177
29
Nov 2014
98
184
29
Dec 2014
99
190
29
Jan 2015
101
197
29
Feb 2015
105
199
30
Mar 2015
107
202
30
Apr 2015
113
203
31
May 2015
113
203
31
Jun 2015
119
206
31
Jul 2015
126
215
31
Aug 2015
130
218
32
Sep 2015
131
221
32
Oct 2015
137
223
32
Nov 2015
143
225
32
Dec 2015
143
231
32
Jan 2016
156
236
33
Feb 2016
166
244
34
Mar 2016
174
245
34
Apr 2016
180
247
34
May 2016
186
248
34
Jun 2016
190
249
34
Jul 2016
197
254
35
Aug 2016
202
255
35
Sep 2016
207
255
35
Oct 2016
212
257
36
Nov 2016
216
257
36
Dec 2016
218
261
36
Jan 2017
224
265
36
Feb 2017
233
269
36
Mar 2017
247
270
36
Apr 2017
268
271
38
May 2017
293
274
42
Jun 2017
312
275
44
Jul 2017
316
275
44
Aug 2017
325
275
44
Sep 2017
328
276
44
Oct 2017
333
276
44
Nov 2017
340
277
44
Dec 2017
347
278
44
Jan 2018
355
279
44
Feb 2018
371
281
49
Mar 2018
380
284
51
Apr 2018
386
286
52
May 2018
395
289
53
Jun 2018
401
291
54
Jul 2018
408
292
55
Aug 2018
415
294
55
Sep 2018
422
302
56
Oct 2018
430
308
57
Nov 2018
441
312
57
Dec 2018
452
317
58
Jan 2019
460
321
58
Feb 2019
465
321
58
Mar 2019
471
324
59
Apr 2019
476
329
60
May 2019
478
331
61
Jun 2019
483
338
63
Jul 2019
491
340
63
Aug 2019
498
346
64
Sep 2019
505
347
64
Oct 2019
509
348
64
Nov 2019
518
350
64
Dec 2019
525
351
64
Jan 2020
539
353
64
Feb 2020
552
357
64
Mar 2020
556
358
65
Apr 2020
562
360
65
May 2020
566
362
65
Jun 2020
569
362
65
Jul 2020
580
369
70
Aug 2020
586
371
73
Sep 2020
590
375
73
Oct 2020
598
378
74
Nov 2020
603
381
75
Dec 2020
609
387
76
Jan 2021
635
394
76
Feb 2021
643
398
76
Mar 2021
649
401
76
Apr 2021
657
404
76
May 2021
680
409
79
Jun 2021
697
415
79
Jul 2021
707
417
80
Aug 2021
716
421
82
Sep 2021
726
423
82
Oct 2021
741
429
83
Nov 2021
753
430
83
Dec 2021
769
438
83
Jan 2022
792
444
84
Feb 2022
806
447
86
Mar 2022
819
451
87
Apr 2022
828
454
87
May 2022
835
456
87
Jun 2022
847
457
87
Jul 2022
850
462
87
Aug 2022
857
464
87
Sep 2022
859
468
87
Oct 2022
868
468
91
Nov 2022
886
474
92
Dec 2022
900
480
92
Jan 2023
905
483
92
Feb 2023
919
488
92
Mar 2023
935
490
92
Apr 2023
939
490
93
May 2023
946
497
95
Jun 2023
964
501
100
Jul 2023
971
503
101
Aug 2023
975
506
101
Sep 2023
985
509
102
Oct 2023
998
515
105
Nov 2023
1,009
516
105
Dec 2023
1,024
516
105
Jan 2024
1,038
516
106
Feb 2024
1,053
519
108
Mar 2024
1,072
523
110
Apr 2024
1,084
526
115
May 2024
1,096
527
115
Jun 2024
1,110
527
117
Jul 2024
1,123
533
121
Aug 2024
1,136
536
121
Sep 2024
1,142
539
121
Oct 2024
1,144
541
121
Nov 2024
1,147
542
122
Latest update: 15 Nov 2024